Deputy Health and Disability Commissioner Rose Wall recently released a report detailing the concerning treatment of two clients by an unnamed disability service provider. The report sheds light on breaches of the Code of Health and Disability Services Consumers’ Rights, raising significant questions about the provider’s conduct and ethics.
Unethical Practices and Overcharges
The first case involved a man with autism who lodged a complaint in November 2022, citing potentially unethical business practices and overcharges by the service provider. The man sought assistance from the provider in navigating WINZ benefits, only to find himself in a predicament where fees were redirected from his benefit without clear communication or justification. Despite expressing concerns over the delayed review of his benefits and the lack of progress in resolving issues, the man encountered defensive behavior from the provider during a subsequent meeting. The provider’s dismissive attitude towards the man’s complaints, coupled with derogatory remarks, further exacerbated the situation, prompting the man to seek a refund and disengagement from the service provider.
Flawed Diagnostic Process
In a separate incident, a woman reported similar concerns about the service provider’s practices in 2023. The provider offered to assist her in obtaining an autism assessment, which resulted in a rushed diagnostic process with questionable transparency and professionalism. The woman’s suspicions were confirmed when she sought a second opinion from a registered psychiatrist, leading to a legitimate diagnosis of autism. The provider’s refusal to provide necessary documentation and the subsequent charging of exorbitant fees for a flawed diagnosis underscored the lack of ethical standards and accountability within the service provider’s operations.
Deputy Health and Disability Commissioner Wall highlighted the gravity of the situation, emphasizing the impact on both individuals’ financial and emotional well-being. The lack of organizational policies and processes within the disability service further compounds the concerns raised by the complainants, pointing to systemic issues that require immediate attention. Wall recommended that the provider issue written apologies to the affected individuals and implement robust policies to guide their advocacy and support efforts. Additionally, she called for reflection and learning on the HDC Code to prevent similar incidents in the future.
As the report gains traction, stakeholders such as the Ministry of Disabled People, the Ministry of Social Development, WINZ, Charities Services, and the Commerce Commission will receive copies for further investigation and potential regulatory action. The findings serve as a stark reminder of the need for stringent oversight and accountability in the provision of disability services, safeguarding the rights and well-being of vulnerable consumers.
Stay informed with Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, our daily newsletter curated by seasoned editors, delivering insightful content straight to your inbox every weekday.